To watch in HD, get ClipCafe PRO

Okay, this is where you wanna get to, right?

Do they make conscious choices? Or is their motivation so instinctive that they don't...

Arrival • 2016

Okay, this is whereyou wanna get to, right? - That is the question.- Okay. So, first, we need to make sure that they understand what a question is. Okay, the nature ofa request for information along with a response. Then, we need to clarifythe difference between a specific "you" and a collective "you," because we don't wanna knowwhy Joe Alien is here, we want to know why they all landed. And purpose requiresan understanding of intent. We need to find out: do they make conscious choices? Or is their motivation so instinctive that they don't understanda "why" question at all? And... And biggest of all, we need to have enoughvocabulary with them that we understand their answer. I get it. Stick to your list. Just don't add anything to it

Full Transcript

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:03.275

Okay this is where you wanna get to right

00:00:03.036 --> 00:00:04.084

That is the question Okay

00:00:04.092 --> 00:00:07.115

So first we need to make sure that

00:00:07.024 --> 00:00:09.031

they understand what a question is

00:00:09.004 --> 00:00:13.188

Okay the nature of a request for information

00:00:13.028 --> 00:00:14.838

along with a response

00:00:14.092 --> 00:00:19.152

Then we need to clarify the difference between

00:00:19.024 --> 00:00:22.357

a specific you and a collective you

00:00:22.044 --> 00:00:26.592

because we don't wanna know why Joe Alien is here

00:00:26.072 --> 00:00:29.553

we want to know why they all landed

00:00:29.068 --> 00:00:33.007

And purpose requires an understanding of intent

00:00:33.016 --> 00:00:34.434

We need to find out

00:00:34.056 --> 00:00:36.471

do they make conscious choices

00:00:36.056 --> 00:00:38.676

Or is their motivation so instinctive

00:00:38.076 --> 00:00:41.797

that they don't understand a why question at all

00:00:41.088 --> 00:00:43.393

And And biggest of all

00:00:43.048 --> 00:00:45.675

we need to have enough vocabulary with them

00:00:45.008 --> 00:00:47.518

that we understand their answer

00:00:50.999 --> 00:00:51.678

I get it

00:00:51.076 --> 00:00:54.115

Stick to your list

00:00:54.002 --> 00:00:55.679

Just

00:00:57.048 --> 00:00:59.471

don't add anything to it

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:04.051

هذا ما تودون طرحه صحيح إنه السؤال المعني

00:00:04.086 --> 00:00:09.252

لذا أول ا علينا أن نفه مهم مفهوم السؤال

00:00:09.642 --> 00:00:15.999

طبيعة طلبنا معلومة بحيث يردان علينا بها

00:00:15.001 --> 00:00:22.486

ثم علينا إيضاح الفرق بين ضميري أنت وأنتم

00:00:22.487 --> 00:00:26.992

لأننا لا نود معرفة غرض فضائي واحد من المجيء

00:00:26.993 --> 00:00:29.812

بل نود معرفة سبب هبوطهم جميع ا

00:00:29.813 --> 00:00:33.324

وهذه غاية تتطل ب فهم نيتهم

00:00:33.325 --> 00:00:36.998

علينا تبين ما إذا كانوا يتخذون خياراتهم بشكل عقلاني

00:00:36.003 --> 00:00:41.311

أم بتحفيز غريزي لحد عدم فهمهم السؤال السببي البت ة

00:00:41.312 --> 00:00:47.042

والأهم أن نملك حصيلة كلمات كافية معهم لفهم أجوبتهم

00:00:49.681 --> 00:00:53.521

مفهوم التزمي بقائمتك

00:00:53.991 --> 00:00:55.765

فقط

00:00:57.023 --> 00:00:58.096

لا تضيفي أي جديد

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:03.001

C'est ce que vous voulez savoir non

00:00:03.252 --> 00:00:04.692

Telle est la question Très bien

00:00:04.712 --> 00:00:07.009

Donc nous devons d'abord être sûrs

00:00:07.131 --> 00:00:09.342

qu'ils comprennent ce qu'est une question

00:00:09.377 --> 00:00:10.051

Oui

00:00:10.001 --> 00:00:13.471

La nature de notre demande d'information

00:00:13.512 --> 00:00:14.931

pour la réponse

00:00:15.999 --> 00:00:18.232

Ensuite nous devons expliquer

00:00:18.267 --> 00:00:20.562

la différence entre un vous spécifique

00:00:20.811 --> 00:00:22.057

et un vous collectif

00:00:22.605 --> 00:00:27.235

Nous ne voulons pas savoir pourquoi l'un d'entre eux en particulier est venu ici

00:00:27.276 --> 00:00:29.571

nous voulons savoir pourquoi ils sont tous venus

00:00:29.778 --> 00:00:32.099

Un objectif nécessite une compréhension de l'intention

00:00:33.999 --> 00:00:36.203

Nous devons savoir s'ils font des choix conscients

00:00:36.243 --> 00:00:38.058

ou si leur motivation est si instinctive

00:00:38.621 --> 00:00:41.249

qu'ils ne comprennent aucune question commençant par pourquoi

00:00:41.332 --> 00:00:45.795

Et surtout nous devons avoir suffisamment de vocabulaire

00:00:45.878 --> 00:00:47.547

pour comprendre leur réponse

00:00:49.757 --> 00:00:51.003

Je comprends

00:00:51.759 --> 00:00:53.261

Tenez vous en à votre liste

00:00:54.001 --> 00:00:55.305

Et

00:00:57.306 --> 00:00:59.003

N'ajoutez rien

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:02.935

Ini yang ingin kau tanyakan kepada mereka bukan

00:00:02.936 --> 00:00:03.996

Ya itu pertanyaannya Baiklah

00:00:04.002 --> 00:00:07.877

Jadi tentu saja kita harus memastikan mereka mengerti

00:00:07.913 --> 00:00:08.973

Apa pertanyaannya

00:00:08.983 --> 00:00:10.976

Dan mereka akan menjawabnya

00:00:11.002 --> 00:00:14.754

Pertanyaan ini mebutuhkan jawaban atau respon dari mereka

00:00:14.794 --> 00:00:17.857

Kemudian kita harus mengklarifikasi

00:00:17.866 --> 00:00:20.077

identitas spesifik mereka apakah ''kau''

00:00:20.806 --> 00:00:21.968

dan ''kalian''

00:00:21.975 --> 00:00:25.914

Karena kita tidak ingin tahu berapa umur alien kita

00:00:25.095 --> 00:00:28.945

kita hanya ingin tahu mengapa mereka mendarat

00:00:28.989 --> 00:00:32.894

Dan tujuan mereka mungkin untuk menghibur

00:00:32.896 --> 00:00:35.891

Kita harus mencari tahu apa yang membuat mereka sadar

00:00:35.936 --> 00:00:37.998

Atau motivasi mereka agar bisa dipastikan bahwa

00:00:38.997 --> 00:00:40.091

Mereka tidak mengerti sama sekali dengan pertanyaan kita

00:00:40.947 --> 00:00:44.944

Dan diatas semuanya itu kita perlu vokabulari yang cukup

00:00:44.955 --> 00:00:46.089

agar kita mengerti jawaban mereka

00:00:49.998 --> 00:00:50.988

Baiklah

00:00:51.969 --> 00:00:52.959

Teruskan saja

00:00:54.001 --> 00:00:58.878

hanya Lakukanlah yang terbaik

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:03.216

これが最終目的ですね

00:00:03.366 --> 00:00:04.738

質問だはい

00:00:04.942 --> 00:00:09.252

ではまず質問の意味を教えねばならない

00:00:09.523 --> 00:00:11.655

返答として

00:00:12.999 --> 00:00:14.988

情報を求める我々の性質

00:00:15.136 --> 00:00:18.001

次に明確にするのは

00:00:18.172 --> 00:00:20.691

個体としてのあなたと

00:00:20.721 --> 00:00:22.459

集合体のあなた

00:00:22.489 --> 00:00:26.964

何故なら個のエイリアンの飛来目的でなく

00:00:27.001 --> 00:00:29.783

全体の目的を知りたいからです

00:00:29.814 --> 00:00:33.297

目的には意思が必要です

00:00:33.327 --> 00:00:36.029

故意の選択の結果か一切の疑問の無い

00:00:36.346 --> 00:00:39.508

無意識の動機なのか我々は

00:00:39.555 --> 00:00:41.466

確かめねばなりません

00:00:41.588 --> 00:00:45.507

そして返事を理解するには十分な語彙が

00:00:45.581 --> 00:00:47.066

絶対に必要なのです

00:00:49.682 --> 00:00:51.183

うん

00:00:51.938 --> 00:00:53.523

リストに従おう

00:00:54.012 --> 00:00:55.367

ただ

00:00:57.597 --> 00:00:59.327

もう何も加えるな

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:04.067

Queremos llegar a esto no Esa es la pregunta

00:00:04.754 --> 00:00:09.055

Primero tienen que entender lo que es una pregunta

00:00:09.717 --> 00:00:14.722

La naturaleza de una solicitud de información y una respuesta

00:00:14.889 --> 00:00:18.517

Luego hay que aclarar la diferencia

00:00:18.601 --> 00:00:22.271

entre el tú singular y el ustedes colectivo

00:00:22.396 --> 00:00:26.525

Porque no nos interesa saber por qué vino Pepe Marciano

00:00:26.609 --> 00:00:29.403

Queremos saber por qué aterrizaron todos

00:00:29.612 --> 00:00:32.948

Y propósito requiere una comprensión de intención

00:00:33.998 --> 00:00:36.202

Hay que averiguar si toman decisiones conscientes

00:00:36.285 --> 00:00:41.248

o si son tan instintivos que no entienden la pregunta Por qué

00:00:41.374 --> 00:00:45.252

Y hay que tener suficiente vocabulario en común

00:00:45.378 --> 00:00:47.588

para entender su respuesta

00:00:49.757 --> 00:00:50.758

Entiendo

00:00:51.759 --> 00:00:53.001

Aténgase a su lista

00:00:54.999 --> 00:00:55.221

Solamente

00:00:57.431 --> 00:00:59.058

no le agregue nada

Available in 6 languages

Duration

61 seconds

Views

83

Timestamp in Movie

00:42:35

Uploaded

Feb 09, 2026

Genres

drama, mystery, sci-fi

Production

FilmNation Entertainment,Lava Bear Films,21 Laps Entertainment

Want This Clip in HD?

Upgrade for HD/4K downloads and unlimited access. Upgrade now →

Movie Summary

A linguist works with the military to communicate with alien lifeforms after twelve mysterious spacecrafts appear around the world.