We're stuck, almost conceptually, between two almost cliché ways of thinking about...
Join the conversation
Log in or create an account to leave a comment
Log In
Michael Hardt:
We're stuck, almost conceptually, between two almost cliché ways of thinking about revolution. On the one hand, we have the notion of revolution that involves the replacement of a ruling elite with another... better-in many ways-ruling elite. And that's sort of the form that many modern revolutions have taken and have posed great benefits for the people but they have not arrived at democracy. So that notion of revolution is really discredited and I think rightly so. But, opposed to that, is another notion of revolution, which I think is equally discredited but from exactly the opposite point of view, which is it's the notion of revolution that, in fact, hasn't been instituted, that thinks of revolution as just the removal of all of those forms of authority, state power, the power of capital, that stop people from expressing their natural abilities to rule themselves
We're stuck, almost conceptually, between two almost cliché ways of thinking about revolution. On the one hand, we have the notion of revolution that involves the replacement of a ruling elite with another... better-in many ways-ruling elite. And that's sort of the form that many modern revolutions have taken and have posed great benefits for the people but they have not arrived at democracy. So that notion of revolution is really discredited and I think rightly so. But, opposed to that, is another notion of revolution, which I think is equally discredited but from exactly the opposite point of view, which is it's the notion of revolution that, in fact, hasn't been instituted, that thinks of revolution as just the removal of all of those forms of authority, state power, the power of capital, that stop people from expressing their natural abilities to rule themselves
Full Transcript
00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:05.437
We're stuck conceptually I think between two almost cliche ways of thinking revolution today
00:00:05.505 --> 00:00:08.044
On the one hand we have
00:00:08.508 --> 00:00:11.477
the notion of revolution that involves
00:00:11.544 --> 00:00:14.098
the replacement of a ruling elite
00:00:15.048 --> 00:00:17.243
with another
00:00:17.316 --> 00:00:19.058
better in many ways ruling elite
00:00:19.652 --> 00:00:23.418
And that's in fact the form that many of the modern revolutions have taken
00:00:23.489 --> 00:00:27.823
and have posed great benefits for the people et cetera but they have not arrived at democracy
00:00:27.894 --> 00:00:32.297
And so that notion of revolution is really discredited and I think rightly so
00:00:32.365 --> 00:00:35.698
But opposed to that is another notion of revolution
Want This Clip in HD?
Upgrade for HD/4K downloads and unlimited access. Upgrade now →
Movie Summary
In Examined Life, filmmaker Astra Taylor accompanies some of today's most influential thinkers on a series of unique excursions through places and spaces that hold particular resonance for them and their ideas.
