To watch in HD, get ClipCafe PRO
Hill: It turns out McReynolds' own daughter
Please log in to add to collections.
How It Really Happened

It turns out McReynolds'own daughter had also been kidnapped22 years earlier, and it also...

Hill: It turns out McReynolds'
own daughter had also been kidnapped
22 years earlier, and it also happened
on Christmas Day

Full Transcript

00:00:01.000 --> 00:00:02.666
Hill: It turns out McReynolds' own daughter
00:00:02.733 --> 00:00:06.133
had also been kidnapped 22 years earlier,
00:00:06.199 --> 00:00:08.005
and it also happened on Christmas Day.
Duration
9 seconds
Views
20
Timestamp in Movie
00:35:30
Uploaded
Jul 13, 2025
Season
5
Episode
9
Genres
documentary, crime, mystery
Production
CNN

Want This Clip in HD?

Upgrade for HD/4K downloads and unlimited access. Upgrade now →

Movie Summary

HLN dives into the deepest, darkest, gruesome mysteries and murders of the past. What really happened and how did it all play out?
S05 • E01 Reporter: 19-year-old Erik Menéndez, accused, - How It Really Happened 00:10
Reporter: 19-year-old Erik Menéndez, accused,
S05 • E04 Alright. Mrs. Robertson, would you -- - How It Really Happened 00:05
Alright. Mrs. Robertson, would you --
S05 • E02 The legal part is over, but the human part continues. - How It Really Happened 00:06
The legal part is over, but the human part continues.
S05 • E06 To me, her happiness was more important than my own. - How It Really Happened 00:04
To me, her happiness was more important than my own.
S05 • E07 This being the middle of the afternoon, very unusual, - How It Really Happened 00:07
This being the middle of the afternoon, very unusual,
S05 • E03 Simpson: During those first nights in jail, - How It Really Happened 00:11
Simpson: During those first nights in jail,
S05 • E05 Dr. Pinsky: In fact, we're hearing - How It Really Happened 00:11
Dr. Pinsky: In fact, we're hearing
S05 • E09 Zesbaugh: His wife had written a play about a little girl - How It Really Happened 00:05
Zesbaugh: His wife had written a play about a little girl
S05 • E08 Reporter: And the mother of the late pop star - How It Really Happened 00:09
Reporter: And the mother of the late pop star
S05 • E02 As the years go by, I think of those guys - How It Really Happened 00:08
As the years go by, I think of those guys
S05 • E04 Alright. Mr. Cochran and Mr. Simpson, - How It Really Happened 00:05
Alright. Mr. Cochran and Mr. Simpson,
S05 • E01 We have some unconfirmed reports that he may in fact - How It Really Happened 00:06
We have some unconfirmed reports that he may in fact
S05 • E10 I'm not particularly happy that the entire thing - How It Really Happened 00:04
I'm not particularly happy that the entire thing
S05 • E04 Hill: I was in the courthouse when the verdict was read, - How It Really Happened 00:05
Hill: I was in the courthouse when the verdict was read,
S05 • E07 I mean, there's an IV pole there, - How It Really Happened 00:08
I mean, there's an IV pole there,
S05 • E09 There were just very bizarre tentacles to this story - How It Really Happened 00:07
There were just very bizarre tentacles to this story
S05 • E01 We don't know what his destination would be - How It Really Happened 00:05
We don't know what his destination would be
S05 • E10 We're not going to get a judge - How It Really Happened 00:10
We're not going to get a judge
S05 • E04 Woman: In the matter of the people of the state of California - How It Really Happened 00:17
Woman: In the matter of the people of the state of Californi...
S05 • E05 What he was taking and what he thought he was taking - How It Really Happened 00:06
What he was taking and what he thought he was taking