Join the conversation
Log in or create an account to leave a comment
Log In
Prof. Rodney Elwell:
Doctor Praetorius, won't you admit that your practice flourished in Goose Creek because you took advantage of the ignorance of its backward inhabitants? Of the pathetic willingness of those poor people to rely upon a belief in miraculous cure rather than scientific knowledge? And because of the readiness with which so many people will prefer the glamorous quack to the licensed practitioner? Doctor Noah Praetorius:
Despite your definition of a quack as someone who does not practice medicine according to your rules, Professor Elwell, the fact remains that a quack is an unqualified person who pretends to be a doctor. I was a licensed practitioner And therefore not a quack. And as to the willingness of those so-called ignorant and backward people to rely upon the curative powers of faith and possibly miracles too, I consider faith properly injected into a patient as effective in maintaining life as adrenaline. And the belief in miracles has been the difference between living and dying as often as any surgeon's scalpel. Prof. Rodney Elwell:
That is not the issue under discussion. Doctor Noah Praetorius:
That is precisely the issue. Whether the practice of medicine shall become more and more intimately involved with the human beings it treats, or whether it's to go on in its present way of becoming more and more a thing of pills, serums and knives until eventually we shall undoubtedly evolve an electronic doctor
Doctor Praetorius, won't you admit that your practice flourished in Goose Creek because you took advantage of the ignorance of its backward inhabitants? Of the pathetic willingness of those poor people to rely upon a belief in miraculous cure rather than scientific knowledge? And because of the readiness with which so many people will prefer the glamorous quack to the licensed practitioner? Doctor Noah Praetorius:
Despite your definition of a quack as someone who does not practice medicine according to your rules, Professor Elwell, the fact remains that a quack is an unqualified person who pretends to be a doctor. I was a licensed practitioner And therefore not a quack. And as to the willingness of those so-called ignorant and backward people to rely upon the curative powers of faith and possibly miracles too, I consider faith properly injected into a patient as effective in maintaining life as adrenaline. And the belief in miracles has been the difference between living and dying as often as any surgeon's scalpel. Prof. Rodney Elwell:
That is not the issue under discussion. Doctor Noah Praetorius:
That is precisely the issue. Whether the practice of medicine shall become more and more intimately involved with the human beings it treats, or whether it's to go on in its present way of becoming more and more a thing of pills, serums and knives until eventually we shall undoubtedly evolve an electronic doctor
Full Transcript
00:00:01.719 --> 00:00:04.847
of the pathetic willingness
of those poor people to rely upon a belief...
00:00:04.922 --> 00:00:08.016
in miraculous cure rather
than scientific knowledge...
00:00:08.001 --> 00:00:11.391
and because of the readiness
with which so many people will prefer...
00:00:11.462 --> 00:00:14.921
the glamourous quack
to the licensed practitioner?
00:00:15.000 --> 00:00:18.492
Despite your definition of a quack
as someone who does not practice medicine...
00:00:18.057 --> 00:00:20.504
according to your rules,
Professor Elwell...
00:00:20.572 --> 00:00:25.168
the fact remains that a quack is an unqualified
person who pretends to be a doctor.
00:00:25.244 --> 00:00:28.771
I was a licensed practitioner,
and therefore, not a quack.
00:00:28.847 --> 00:00:32.248
And as to the willingness of those
so-called ignorant and backward people...
00:00:32.318 --> 00:00:36.516
to rely upon the curative powers of faith
and possibly miracles too...
00:00:36.588 --> 00:00:38.556
I consider faith, properly
injected into a patient...
00:00:38.624 --> 00:00:40.751
as effective in maintaining life
as adrenaline.
00:00:40.826 --> 00:00:44.193
And a belief in miracles has been
the difference between living and dying...
00:00:44.263 --> 00:00:46.254
as often as
any surgeon's scalpel.
00:00:46.332 --> 00:00:50.166
- That is not the issue under discussion.
- It is precisely the issue!
00:00:50.235 --> 00:00:53.466
Whether the practice of medicine
should become more intimately involved...
00:00:53.539 --> 00:00:55.838
with the human beings
it treats...
00:00:55.909 --> 00:00:58.104
or whether it's to go on
in this present way of becoming...
00:00:58.178 --> 00:01:00.084
more and more a thing of pills,
serums and knives...
00:01:00.914 --> 00:01:04.001
until eventually we shall
undoubtedly evolve an electronic doctor.
00:01:04.351 --> 00:01:08.185
The issue at hand is simply that you amassed
a fortune by treating sick people...
00:01:08.254 --> 00:01:11.246
who believed that you were
a miracle-working butcher.
00:01:11.324 --> 00:01:13.999
I could not have amassed
that fortune...
00:01:13.066 --> 00:01:17.221
unless I had made an enormous
number of sick people well!
00:01:17.297 --> 00:01:19.999
All this folderol, as I see it...
00:01:19.001 --> 00:01:23.999
has got nothing to do with
the ethics and honor of our profession.
00:01:23.169 --> 00:01:27.999
It has everything to do with envy
of one man's genius for healing the sick...
00:01:27.001 --> 00:01:31.999
ofhis use of remedies you can't prescribe,
buy in bottles or apply with a knife.
00:01:31.511 --> 00:01:34.001
Call Praetorius a psychiatrist, high priest...
00:01:34.114 --> 00:01:37.881
voodoo, medicine man,
witch doctor, anything you like...
00:01:37.952 --> 00:01:40.785
but don't investigate him,
gentlemen, learn from him.
00:01:40.855 --> 00:01:44.999
Professor Barker, it was understood
you would not interrupt.
00:01:44.425 --> 00:01:46.518
I'm sorry.
00:01:46.999 --> 00:01:48.926
You can strike my remarks
from the record.
00:01:48.996 --> 00:01:52.989
I'm sure you all agree with me anyway,
so why don't we call this silly thing off...
00:01:53.993 --> 00:01:55.331
and start the concert.
00:02:01.003 --> 00:02:03.003
It would interest me,
Dr. Praetorius...
00:02:03.998 --> 00:02:05.999
to know why you ever left
this lucrative practice in Goose Creek...
00:02:05.913 --> 00:02:07.001
and under what circumstances.
00:02:07.848 --> 00:02:12.376
I'd always intended to leave when I'd acquired
enough money to start a clinic of my own.
00:02:12.453 --> 00:02:15.999
As it turned out,
I left a little sooner than I'd planned.
00:02:15.001 --> 00:02:18.691
I fired my housekeeper.
She was falsifying my grocery bills...
00:02:18.999 --> 00:02:20.001
and splitting the money
with the grocer.
00:02:21.996 --> 00:02:23.001
Unfortunately, she had
previously discovered...
00:02:23.001 --> 00:02:27.999
my medical diploma
in a bottom drawer of my desk.
00:02:27.202 --> 00:02:30.001
In revenge for being fired,
she let it be known around Goose Creek...
00:02:30.999 --> 00:02:34.001
that I was not a butcher at all,
but a licensed M.D.
00:02:34.376 --> 00:02:39.001
I was confronted by a crowd of angry
townspeople and forced to admit the truth.
00:02:39.999 --> 00:02:43.999
I narrowly escaped being
run out of town on a rail.
00:02:46.002 --> 00:02:48.987
Any more questions,
Professor Elwell?
00:02:48.999 --> 00:02:51.149
A great many more.
Thank you.
00:02:51.001 --> 00:02:54.999
[Crowd Chattering]
00:03:03.673 --> 00:03:05.607
Shh! Shh!
00:03:24.999 --> 00:03:27.999
- Professor Barker.
- May I point out that these monkeyshines...
00:03:27.999 --> 00:03:30.364
are seriously delaying
the concert of our student orchestra?
00:03:30.999 --> 00:03:33.999
Our concern here is
the future good and welfare of our students...
00:03:33.001 --> 00:03:36.166
as doctors of medicine,
not as troubadours.
00:03:36.239 --> 00:03:40.999
- Were you recognized?
- We're all concerned about the delay of the concert.
00:03:40.511 --> 00:03:43.999
The fact that this hearing conflicts with it
is a most unfortunate coincidence.
00:03:43.999 --> 00:03:46.001
You don't believe that
any more than I do.
00:03:46.999 --> 00:03:48.999
Continue, Professor Elwell.
00:03:54.001 --> 00:03:58.001
- Dr. Praetorius.
- I thought you'd forgotten me.
00:03:59.012 --> 00:04:01.001
Who is Shunderson?
00:04:03.333 --> 00:04:05.999
I take it you mean Mr. Shunderson.
00:04:05.869 --> 00:04:08.999
Mr. Shunderson is my friend.
00:04:08.001 --> 00:04:11.001
Is he associated
with you professionally?
00:04:11.642 --> 00:04:15.999
Not as a professional.
He helps at whatever he can.
00:04:17.003 --> 00:04:22.002
He is also employed in your home
as a manservant or a butler, is he not?
00:04:22.003 --> 00:04:25.999
I do not employ him at all.
He works at whatever he pleases...
00:04:25.002 --> 00:04:27.998
where he pleases and when.
00:04:27.959 --> 00:04:31.002
He is never very far from
your side or for long it seems.
00:04:31.002 --> 00:04:35.999
- Really?
- Dr. Praetorius...
00:04:35.998 --> 00:04:39.166
what was Mr. Shunderson
before you knew him?
Want This Clip in HD?
Upgrade for HD/4K downloads and unlimited access. Upgrade now →
Movie Summary
Dr. Noah Praetorius falls in love with Debra, a student who finds out that she is pregnant by her old boyfriend.
